J.J. McCarthyorJoe Milton III?

Week 11 start/sit decision, quarterback versus quarterback.

Our call

Start J.J. McCarthy

J.J. McCarthy outscores Joe Milton III in 91% of simulations.

Joe Milton III comes out ahead in the other 9%. J.J. McCarthy projects 7.6 half-PPR points ahead in Week 11. Joe Milton III has the better matchup against the Pittsburgh Steelers (1% more than average to QBs); J.J. McCarthy faces the Jacksonville Jaguars (12% fewer than average to QBs). J.J. McCarthy still wins more often despite that.

Range of outcomes, half-PPR

J.J. McCarthy
Floor
5.0
Median
10.9
Ceiling
20.1
Big game (25+):
4%
Dud (under 12):
56%
Joe Milton III
Floor
1.7
Median
3.8
Ceiling
7.2
Big game (25+):
<1%
Dud (under 12):
>99%

Each week is simulated thousands of times from the projection and the player’s usual week-to-week swing. Floor and ceiling are the 10th and 90th percentile: 8 weeks in 10 land between them.

Share this

StatJ.J. McCarthyQB, NYG, Sun, Nov 22, 1:00 p.m. ETJoe Milton IIIQB, PHI, Sun, Nov 22, 4:25 p.m. ET
Half-PPR projection11.84.2
PPR projection11.84.2
Standard projection11.84.2
Rank this weekQB19QB23
Matchupvs JAXvs PIT
InjuryNoneNone
2026 points per game10.213.2
Last season per game12.52.6
Snap share, last game95%100%
Trade value——